Who benefited from the demise of the FTAA?

Hugo Marcelo Balderrama

By: Hugo Marcelo Balderrama - 19/11/2026

Guest columnist.
Share:     Share in whatsapp

After the collapse of the USSR, the West bought into Fukuyama's "End of History" thesis. We popped the champagne, thinking that the great ideological disputes and totalitarian threats had been buried under the rubble of the Berlin Wall.

However, during that same period, Yevgeny Primakov, one of those nostalgics who refused to accept the end of the USSR, used his position as Foreign Minister in Boris Yeltsin's government to formulate his doctrine of national security and geopolitics for 21st-century Russia. The central thesis was as follows:

Russia must aspire to a multipolar world governed by a concert of great powers. Therefore, the first step is to distance itself from the West and seek alliances with China, India, and Iran. Furthermore, it must restructure its existing alliances within the West.

One of those allies was, almost naturally, the Latin American left, rearticulated in the Sao Paulo Forum. The central point of agreement was to displace US influence in Latin America and erode support for Western democratic norms.

They wasted no time in putting their plans into action. As soon as the 21st century began, the horde of activists from the São Paulo Forum launched a disinformation campaign about the Free Trade Area of ​​the Americas (FTAA). Their narrative was classic anti-Americanism. But they didn't limit themselves to filling public opinion with anti-imperialist superstitions and a reheated Castroism; with the active support of Hugo Chávez, they instigated armed uprisings and coups d'état in Ecuador, Argentina, and Bolivia.

In November 2005, in Mar del Plata, Néstor Kirchner convened Hugo Chávez, Evo Morales, and Diego Maradona to celebrate the defeat of neoliberalism and the burial of the FTAA. A crucial point is that significant sectors of the industrial business community also opposed the FTAA. The clearest example was Brazilian business, which coordinated with Lula's government to support a strategy of "industrialization" and "strengthening" regional value chains. However, this was not a genuine interest in the national economy, but rather nefarious agreements between mercenaries of easy money, who seek any means to avoid competition, and Lula da Silva's cronies. In 1776, Adam Smith wisely dubbed such individuals "white-collar thieves."

A valid question arises here: Who truly benefited from the failure of the FTAA?

Simply put: Economically, China; in terms of weaponry and narrative influence, Russia; and geopolitically, Iran. Let's take a look:

To date, China has consolidated 26% of trade with Latin America. It is estimated that by 2040 the total amount traded will reach $700 billion. If this trend continues, by the end of the next decade China will have surpassed the US as the main trading partner of our countries. In this regard, Douglas Farah, in his book: Trilateral Authoritarian Alliance, explains the following:

This is certainly true in the case of the inauguration of the new megaport of Chancay, in Peru, valued at $1.3 billion and presented by Chinese media as the crown jewel of the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI), which will revolutionize global supply chains. No mention was made of the usurpation of Peruvian sovereignty or China's new control of a key point for regional trade.

For their part, Cuba, Nicaragua, and Venezuela have allowed the installation of Russian military bases on their territory. During the Mexican Independence Day celebrations (September 2023) in Mexico City, a contingent of 15 Russian soldiers marched. Furthermore, to achieve media dominance, Russia invested substantial resources in the Latin American market, something others have not done, either before or now. RT en Español has a staff of more than 30 journalists in Latin America. The Russian narrative strategy in Latin America focuses on blaming the US for any political, social, or economic problems in the region. Its effectiveness rests on the activities of RT en Español and Sputnik Mundo, as well as echo chambers like CLACSO, which uses every platform to disseminate narratives and propaganda in favor of Putin's dictatorship.

Furthermore, on numerous occasions, Iranian leaders have expressed their clear objective of strengthening relations with Latin America. In September 2007, the Deputy Minister of Islamic Guidance for Film Affairs, Mohammad Reza Yaafari Yelve, said:

Expanding and deepening cultural relations between countries like Iran and Venezuela, which have a rich cultural heritage and an ancient history, is the most effective way to confront the current aggressions of the US and its imperialist plans.

Under Chávez's leadership, Iran strengthened its ties with Nicaragua, Bolivia, and Ecuador. In April 2007, Daniel Ortega officially endorsed Iran's uranium enrichment program. For its part, Tehran pledged to support more than thirty projects, primarily in hydroelectric power generation.

Although the region shares no common identity with Iran, the ayatollahs are clear that modifying the cultural foundations of the United States' neighbors and securing military allies in the region are the most effective mechanisms for weakening American hegemony. For example, in September 2005, at a meeting of the IAEA Board of Governors, Venezuela was the only country that voted against the resolution that would have allowed the referral of the Iranian nuclear program to the Security Council.

In conclusion, our region has become an active part of the Global War, one that is fought not only with traditional armies, but also with narratives, disinformation, organized crime, economic pressures, and diplomacy.


«The opinions published herein are the sole responsibility of its author».